#176000: "A list of important additions/edits"
Tentang apa laporan ini?
Apa yang terjadi? Pilih di bawah
Apa yang terjadi? Pilih di bawah
Silakan periksa apakah sudah ada laporan tentang hal yang sama
Jika ya, silakan VOTE untuk laporan ini. Laporan dengan suara terbanyak diberikan PRIORITAS!
| # | Status | Votes | Game | Type | Title | Last update |
|---|
Detil Deskripsi
-
• Mohon salin/tempel pesan error yang Anda lihat di layar, jika ada.
Hello, I’m steal36 and I just played your game for the first time. I like it a lot! I haven’t experienced any major bugs and it all ran very smoothly as a poker game should. However, I noticed a few small things that could be slightly edited in order to enhance the player experience, if you are open to feedback that is. Allow me to list my initial observations and ideas for you. (Note: I'm aware BGA requests to write one bug per report but I have too many to list them all sepparately so forgive me if this is a lot, and some might repeat what other users have suggested).
- There should be a slider dial to decide how much to bid. I’m not a fan of the current system with 6 options up top plus a custom option where you have to enter a number, it’s just clunky. Give us a slider near our tokens, give us the option to bid small, half or all in, and then a confirm button.
Side note: I didn’t initially see all the toggleable settings under the table screen (and mind you I am playing on the widest display option on a MacBook Pro) because I had to scroll down for it. So a lot of my initial suggestions when I started writing this were all things that you’ve already implemented the option for. What I’d suggest instead is bringing up those options (there’s space for it on the board) or an other form of indication that they’re there, otherwise players might miss it if they don’t think to scroll.
- Small bug I noticed, halfway through the game I unselected the “ask to reveal hands” option and then a few rounds later reselected it, but it wouldn’t give me the cue to reveal my cards anymore. For that reason I wasn’t able to test this next point but in case there isn’t a time limit:
- There should be a time limit on the option to reveal or not show cards.
- There should be less crowding in the actions summary section (not sure what its called), just the important information on how much each player bets, i.e. “player bets 4” “player raises 6”, no need for “__ is now the active player” and no need to notify us every time money moves from a player to their betting pile and from the betting pile to the pot its just too much. You could even remove the game moves like “a 4 is revealed” when I can already see that on the board. No need for “cards have been shuffled” “2 was dealt to each player” etc.
Additionally, the hands at the end don’t fully fit in the recap so it looks clunky cause its 4 cards in a row and one below it, so just scrap that.
- The little colored number titled “the amount of money “player” bet for this betting round” should just disappear when they fold instead of staying on the board as 0.
- What would help new players is a little text below their hand telling them what they currently have, and if you can afford to program it, maybe even a percentage chance of winning like they do in real tournaments.
- There should be chips that say small and big blind, like the dealer chip, instead of a chat bubble above the players saying “I placed a small blind”
- When a player is eliminated, their whole presence should be wiped from the board, as opposed to keeping a large empty semi-transparent box with their name in it and no cards.
- A player’s cards should be greyed out when they fold, instead of disappearing, so they can still see what they ‘would’ve’ had if they continued to play.
Hope these suggestions help you, if you choose to implement some or all of them great, but in either case, thanks for adding this to BGA and good luck with the continued development of your game!
Sincerely,
steal36 -
• Mohon jelaskan apa yang ingin Anda lakukan, apa yang kemudian Anda lakukan, dan apa yang terjadi
• Apa browser yang Anda gunakan?
Google Chrome v137
-
• Harap salin/tempel teks yang ditampilkan dalam bahasa Inggris alih-alih bahasa anda. Jika kamu memunyai screenshot dari sebuah kesalahan (praktik bagus) kamu busa menggunakan gambar untuk menandakan pilihan servis anda (snipboard.io for example) untuk mengunggah itu dan salin/tempel tautan disini apakah teks ini tersedia dalam translation system? jika iya, itu bisa diartikan lebih dari 24 jam
Hello, I’m steal36 and I just played your game for the first time. I like it a lot! I haven’t experienced any major bugs and it all ran very smoothly as a poker game should. However, I noticed a few small things that could be slightly edited in order to enhance the player experience, if you are open to feedback that is. Allow me to list my initial observations and ideas for you. (Note: I'm aware BGA requests to write one bug per report but I have too many to list them all sepparately so forgive me if this is a lot, and some might repeat what other users have suggested).
- There should be a slider dial to decide how much to bid. I’m not a fan of the current system with 6 options up top plus a custom option where you have to enter a number, it’s just clunky. Give us a slider near our tokens, give us the option to bid small, half or all in, and then a confirm button.
Side note: I didn’t initially see all the toggleable settings under the table screen (and mind you I am playing on the widest display option on a MacBook Pro) because I had to scroll down for it. So a lot of my initial suggestions when I started writing this were all things that you’ve already implemented the option for. What I’d suggest instead is bringing up those options (there’s space for it on the board) or an other form of indication that they’re there, otherwise players might miss it if they don’t think to scroll.
- Small bug I noticed, halfway through the game I unselected the “ask to reveal hands” option and then a few rounds later reselected it, but it wouldn’t give me the cue to reveal my cards anymore. For that reason I wasn’t able to test this next point but in case there isn’t a time limit:
- There should be a time limit on the option to reveal or not show cards.
- There should be less crowding in the actions summary section (not sure what its called), just the important information on how much each player bets, i.e. “player bets 4” “player raises 6”, no need for “__ is now the active player” and no need to notify us every time money moves from a player to their betting pile and from the betting pile to the pot its just too much. You could even remove the game moves like “a 4 is revealed” when I can already see that on the board. No need for “cards have been shuffled” “2 was dealt to each player” etc.
Additionally, the hands at the end don’t fully fit in the recap so it looks clunky cause its 4 cards in a row and one below it, so just scrap that.
- The little colored number titled “the amount of money “player” bet for this betting round” should just disappear when they fold instead of staying on the board as 0.
- What would help new players is a little text below their hand telling them what they currently have, and if you can afford to program it, maybe even a percentage chance of winning like they do in real tournaments.
- There should be chips that say small and big blind, like the dealer chip, instead of a chat bubble above the players saying “I placed a small blind”
- When a player is eliminated, their whole presence should be wiped from the board, as opposed to keeping a large empty semi-transparent box with their name in it and no cards.
- A player’s cards should be greyed out when they fold, instead of disappearing, so they can still see what they ‘would’ve’ had if they continued to play.
Hope these suggestions help you, if you choose to implement some or all of them great, but in either case, thanks for adding this to BGA and good luck with the continued development of your game!
Sincerely,
steal36 • Apa browser yang Anda gunakan?
Google Chrome v137
-
• Tolong jelaskan saran Anda secara tepat dan ringkas sehingga semudah mungkin untuk memahami apa yang Anda maksud.
Hello, I’m steal36 and I just played your game for the first time. I like it a lot! I haven’t experienced any major bugs and it all ran very smoothly as a poker game should. However, I noticed a few small things that could be slightly edited in order to enhance the player experience, if you are open to feedback that is. Allow me to list my initial observations and ideas for you. (Note: I'm aware BGA requests to write one bug per report but I have too many to list them all sepparately so forgive me if this is a lot, and some might repeat what other users have suggested).
- There should be a slider dial to decide how much to bid. I’m not a fan of the current system with 6 options up top plus a custom option where you have to enter a number, it’s just clunky. Give us a slider near our tokens, give us the option to bid small, half or all in, and then a confirm button.
Side note: I didn’t initially see all the toggleable settings under the table screen (and mind you I am playing on the widest display option on a MacBook Pro) because I had to scroll down for it. So a lot of my initial suggestions when I started writing this were all things that you’ve already implemented the option for. What I’d suggest instead is bringing up those options (there’s space for it on the board) or an other form of indication that they’re there, otherwise players might miss it if they don’t think to scroll.
- Small bug I noticed, halfway through the game I unselected the “ask to reveal hands” option and then a few rounds later reselected it, but it wouldn’t give me the cue to reveal my cards anymore. For that reason I wasn’t able to test this next point but in case there isn’t a time limit:
- There should be a time limit on the option to reveal or not show cards.
- There should be less crowding in the actions summary section (not sure what its called), just the important information on how much each player bets, i.e. “player bets 4” “player raises 6”, no need for “__ is now the active player” and no need to notify us every time money moves from a player to their betting pile and from the betting pile to the pot its just too much. You could even remove the game moves like “a 4 is revealed” when I can already see that on the board. No need for “cards have been shuffled” “2 was dealt to each player” etc.
Additionally, the hands at the end don’t fully fit in the recap so it looks clunky cause its 4 cards in a row and one below it, so just scrap that.
- The little colored number titled “the amount of money “player” bet for this betting round” should just disappear when they fold instead of staying on the board as 0.
- What would help new players is a little text below their hand telling them what they currently have, and if you can afford to program it, maybe even a percentage chance of winning like they do in real tournaments.
- There should be chips that say small and big blind, like the dealer chip, instead of a chat bubble above the players saying “I placed a small blind”
- When a player is eliminated, their whole presence should be wiped from the board, as opposed to keeping a large empty semi-transparent box with their name in it and no cards.
- A player’s cards should be greyed out when they fold, instead of disappearing, so they can still see what they ‘would’ve’ had if they continued to play.
Hope these suggestions help you, if you choose to implement some or all of them great, but in either case, thanks for adding this to BGA and good luck with the continued development of your game!
Sincerely,
steal36 • Apa browser yang Anda gunakan?
Google Chrome v137
-
• Apa yang tampil di layar ketika Anda tidak dapat berjalan (Layar kosong? Hanya tampil sebagian antar-muka? Pesan error?)
Hello, I’m steal36 and I just played your game for the first time. I like it a lot! I haven’t experienced any major bugs and it all ran very smoothly as a poker game should. However, I noticed a few small things that could be slightly edited in order to enhance the player experience, if you are open to feedback that is. Allow me to list my initial observations and ideas for you. (Note: I'm aware BGA requests to write one bug per report but I have too many to list them all sepparately so forgive me if this is a lot, and some might repeat what other users have suggested).
- There should be a slider dial to decide how much to bid. I’m not a fan of the current system with 6 options up top plus a custom option where you have to enter a number, it’s just clunky. Give us a slider near our tokens, give us the option to bid small, half or all in, and then a confirm button.
Side note: I didn’t initially see all the toggleable settings under the table screen (and mind you I am playing on the widest display option on a MacBook Pro) because I had to scroll down for it. So a lot of my initial suggestions when I started writing this were all things that you’ve already implemented the option for. What I’d suggest instead is bringing up those options (there’s space for it on the board) or an other form of indication that they’re there, otherwise players might miss it if they don’t think to scroll.
- Small bug I noticed, halfway through the game I unselected the “ask to reveal hands” option and then a few rounds later reselected it, but it wouldn’t give me the cue to reveal my cards anymore. For that reason I wasn’t able to test this next point but in case there isn’t a time limit:
- There should be a time limit on the option to reveal or not show cards.
- There should be less crowding in the actions summary section (not sure what its called), just the important information on how much each player bets, i.e. “player bets 4” “player raises 6”, no need for “__ is now the active player” and no need to notify us every time money moves from a player to their betting pile and from the betting pile to the pot its just too much. You could even remove the game moves like “a 4 is revealed” when I can already see that on the board. No need for “cards have been shuffled” “2 was dealt to each player” etc.
Additionally, the hands at the end don’t fully fit in the recap so it looks clunky cause its 4 cards in a row and one below it, so just scrap that.
- The little colored number titled “the amount of money “player” bet for this betting round” should just disappear when they fold instead of staying on the board as 0.
- What would help new players is a little text below their hand telling them what they currently have, and if you can afford to program it, maybe even a percentage chance of winning like they do in real tournaments.
- There should be chips that say small and big blind, like the dealer chip, instead of a chat bubble above the players saying “I placed a small blind”
- When a player is eliminated, their whole presence should be wiped from the board, as opposed to keeping a large empty semi-transparent box with their name in it and no cards.
- A player’s cards should be greyed out when they fold, instead of disappearing, so they can still see what they ‘would’ve’ had if they continued to play.
Hope these suggestions help you, if you choose to implement some or all of them great, but in either case, thanks for adding this to BGA and good luck with the continued development of your game!
Sincerely,
steal36 • Apa browser yang Anda gunakan?
Google Chrome v137
-
• Bagian mana dari peraturan yang tidak diterapkan dengan tepat oleh BGA
Hello, I’m steal36 and I just played your game for the first time. I like it a lot! I haven’t experienced any major bugs and it all ran very smoothly as a poker game should. However, I noticed a few small things that could be slightly edited in order to enhance the player experience, if you are open to feedback that is. Allow me to list my initial observations and ideas for you. (Note: I'm aware BGA requests to write one bug per report but I have too many to list them all sepparately so forgive me if this is a lot, and some might repeat what other users have suggested).
- There should be a slider dial to decide how much to bid. I’m not a fan of the current system with 6 options up top plus a custom option where you have to enter a number, it’s just clunky. Give us a slider near our tokens, give us the option to bid small, half or all in, and then a confirm button.
Side note: I didn’t initially see all the toggleable settings under the table screen (and mind you I am playing on the widest display option on a MacBook Pro) because I had to scroll down for it. So a lot of my initial suggestions when I started writing this were all things that you’ve already implemented the option for. What I’d suggest instead is bringing up those options (there’s space for it on the board) or an other form of indication that they’re there, otherwise players might miss it if they don’t think to scroll.
- Small bug I noticed, halfway through the game I unselected the “ask to reveal hands” option and then a few rounds later reselected it, but it wouldn’t give me the cue to reveal my cards anymore. For that reason I wasn’t able to test this next point but in case there isn’t a time limit:
- There should be a time limit on the option to reveal or not show cards.
- There should be less crowding in the actions summary section (not sure what its called), just the important information on how much each player bets, i.e. “player bets 4” “player raises 6”, no need for “__ is now the active player” and no need to notify us every time money moves from a player to their betting pile and from the betting pile to the pot its just too much. You could even remove the game moves like “a 4 is revealed” when I can already see that on the board. No need for “cards have been shuffled” “2 was dealt to each player” etc.
Additionally, the hands at the end don’t fully fit in the recap so it looks clunky cause its 4 cards in a row and one below it, so just scrap that.
- The little colored number titled “the amount of money “player” bet for this betting round” should just disappear when they fold instead of staying on the board as 0.
- What would help new players is a little text below their hand telling them what they currently have, and if you can afford to program it, maybe even a percentage chance of winning like they do in real tournaments.
- There should be chips that say small and big blind, like the dealer chip, instead of a chat bubble above the players saying “I placed a small blind”
- When a player is eliminated, their whole presence should be wiped from the board, as opposed to keeping a large empty semi-transparent box with their name in it and no cards.
- A player’s cards should be greyed out when they fold, instead of disappearing, so they can still see what they ‘would’ve’ had if they continued to play.
Hope these suggestions help you, if you choose to implement some or all of them great, but in either case, thanks for adding this to BGA and good luck with the continued development of your game!
Sincerely,
steal36 -
• Apakah kesalahan peraturan dapat dilihat dari ulangan permainan? Jika ya, pada langkah ke berapa?
• Apa browser yang Anda gunakan?
Google Chrome v137
-
• Aksi permainan apa yang ingin Anda lakukan?
Hello, I’m steal36 and I just played your game for the first time. I like it a lot! I haven’t experienced any major bugs and it all ran very smoothly as a poker game should. However, I noticed a few small things that could be slightly edited in order to enhance the player experience, if you are open to feedback that is. Allow me to list my initial observations and ideas for you. (Note: I'm aware BGA requests to write one bug per report but I have too many to list them all sepparately so forgive me if this is a lot, and some might repeat what other users have suggested).
- There should be a slider dial to decide how much to bid. I’m not a fan of the current system with 6 options up top plus a custom option where you have to enter a number, it’s just clunky. Give us a slider near our tokens, give us the option to bid small, half or all in, and then a confirm button.
Side note: I didn’t initially see all the toggleable settings under the table screen (and mind you I am playing on the widest display option on a MacBook Pro) because I had to scroll down for it. So a lot of my initial suggestions when I started writing this were all things that you’ve already implemented the option for. What I’d suggest instead is bringing up those options (there’s space for it on the board) or an other form of indication that they’re there, otherwise players might miss it if they don’t think to scroll.
- Small bug I noticed, halfway through the game I unselected the “ask to reveal hands” option and then a few rounds later reselected it, but it wouldn’t give me the cue to reveal my cards anymore. For that reason I wasn’t able to test this next point but in case there isn’t a time limit:
- There should be a time limit on the option to reveal or not show cards.
- There should be less crowding in the actions summary section (not sure what its called), just the important information on how much each player bets, i.e. “player bets 4” “player raises 6”, no need for “__ is now the active player” and no need to notify us every time money moves from a player to their betting pile and from the betting pile to the pot its just too much. You could even remove the game moves like “a 4 is revealed” when I can already see that on the board. No need for “cards have been shuffled” “2 was dealt to each player” etc.
Additionally, the hands at the end don’t fully fit in the recap so it looks clunky cause its 4 cards in a row and one below it, so just scrap that.
- The little colored number titled “the amount of money “player” bet for this betting round” should just disappear when they fold instead of staying on the board as 0.
- What would help new players is a little text below their hand telling them what they currently have, and if you can afford to program it, maybe even a percentage chance of winning like they do in real tournaments.
- There should be chips that say small and big blind, like the dealer chip, instead of a chat bubble above the players saying “I placed a small blind”
- When a player is eliminated, their whole presence should be wiped from the board, as opposed to keeping a large empty semi-transparent box with their name in it and no cards.
- A player’s cards should be greyed out when they fold, instead of disappearing, so they can still see what they ‘would’ve’ had if they continued to play.
Hope these suggestions help you, if you choose to implement some or all of them great, but in either case, thanks for adding this to BGA and good luck with the continued development of your game!
Sincerely,
steal36 -
• Apa yang Anda coba lakukan untuk memunculkan aksi permainan ini?
-
• Apa yang terjadi ketika Anda melakukannya (pesan error, pesan status permainan, ...)?
• Apa browser yang Anda gunakan?
Google Chrome v137
-
• Pada langkah ke berapa masalah tersebut muncul (apa petunjuk permainan saat itu)?
Hello, I’m steal36 and I just played your game for the first time. I like it a lot! I haven’t experienced any major bugs and it all ran very smoothly as a poker game should. However, I noticed a few small things that could be slightly edited in order to enhance the player experience, if you are open to feedback that is. Allow me to list my initial observations and ideas for you. (Note: I'm aware BGA requests to write one bug per report but I have too many to list them all sepparately so forgive me if this is a lot, and some might repeat what other users have suggested).
- There should be a slider dial to decide how much to bid. I’m not a fan of the current system with 6 options up top plus a custom option where you have to enter a number, it’s just clunky. Give us a slider near our tokens, give us the option to bid small, half or all in, and then a confirm button.
Side note: I didn’t initially see all the toggleable settings under the table screen (and mind you I am playing on the widest display option on a MacBook Pro) because I had to scroll down for it. So a lot of my initial suggestions when I started writing this were all things that you’ve already implemented the option for. What I’d suggest instead is bringing up those options (there’s space for it on the board) or an other form of indication that they’re there, otherwise players might miss it if they don’t think to scroll.
- Small bug I noticed, halfway through the game I unselected the “ask to reveal hands” option and then a few rounds later reselected it, but it wouldn’t give me the cue to reveal my cards anymore. For that reason I wasn’t able to test this next point but in case there isn’t a time limit:
- There should be a time limit on the option to reveal or not show cards.
- There should be less crowding in the actions summary section (not sure what its called), just the important information on how much each player bets, i.e. “player bets 4” “player raises 6”, no need for “__ is now the active player” and no need to notify us every time money moves from a player to their betting pile and from the betting pile to the pot its just too much. You could even remove the game moves like “a 4 is revealed” when I can already see that on the board. No need for “cards have been shuffled” “2 was dealt to each player” etc.
Additionally, the hands at the end don’t fully fit in the recap so it looks clunky cause its 4 cards in a row and one below it, so just scrap that.
- The little colored number titled “the amount of money “player” bet for this betting round” should just disappear when they fold instead of staying on the board as 0.
- What would help new players is a little text below their hand telling them what they currently have, and if you can afford to program it, maybe even a percentage chance of winning like they do in real tournaments.
- There should be chips that say small and big blind, like the dealer chip, instead of a chat bubble above the players saying “I placed a small blind”
- When a player is eliminated, their whole presence should be wiped from the board, as opposed to keeping a large empty semi-transparent box with their name in it and no cards.
- A player’s cards should be greyed out when they fold, instead of disappearing, so they can still see what they ‘would’ve’ had if they continued to play.
Hope these suggestions help you, if you choose to implement some or all of them great, but in either case, thanks for adding this to BGA and good luck with the continued development of your game!
Sincerely,
steal36 -
• Apa yang terjadi ketika Anda mencoba untuk melakukan aksi permainan (pesan error, pesan status permainan, ...)?
• Apa browser yang Anda gunakan?
Google Chrome v137
-
• Mohon jelaskan masalah tampilannya. Jika kamu memunyai screenshot dari sebuah kesalahan (praktik bagus) kamu busa menggunakan gambar untuk menandakan pilihan servis anda (snipboard.io for example) untuk mengunggah itu dan salin/tempel tautan disini
Hello, I’m steal36 and I just played your game for the first time. I like it a lot! I haven’t experienced any major bugs and it all ran very smoothly as a poker game should. However, I noticed a few small things that could be slightly edited in order to enhance the player experience, if you are open to feedback that is. Allow me to list my initial observations and ideas for you. (Note: I'm aware BGA requests to write one bug per report but I have too many to list them all sepparately so forgive me if this is a lot, and some might repeat what other users have suggested).
- There should be a slider dial to decide how much to bid. I’m not a fan of the current system with 6 options up top plus a custom option where you have to enter a number, it’s just clunky. Give us a slider near our tokens, give us the option to bid small, half or all in, and then a confirm button.
Side note: I didn’t initially see all the toggleable settings under the table screen (and mind you I am playing on the widest display option on a MacBook Pro) because I had to scroll down for it. So a lot of my initial suggestions when I started writing this were all things that you’ve already implemented the option for. What I’d suggest instead is bringing up those options (there’s space for it on the board) or an other form of indication that they’re there, otherwise players might miss it if they don’t think to scroll.
- Small bug I noticed, halfway through the game I unselected the “ask to reveal hands” option and then a few rounds later reselected it, but it wouldn’t give me the cue to reveal my cards anymore. For that reason I wasn’t able to test this next point but in case there isn’t a time limit:
- There should be a time limit on the option to reveal or not show cards.
- There should be less crowding in the actions summary section (not sure what its called), just the important information on how much each player bets, i.e. “player bets 4” “player raises 6”, no need for “__ is now the active player” and no need to notify us every time money moves from a player to their betting pile and from the betting pile to the pot its just too much. You could even remove the game moves like “a 4 is revealed” when I can already see that on the board. No need for “cards have been shuffled” “2 was dealt to each player” etc.
Additionally, the hands at the end don’t fully fit in the recap so it looks clunky cause its 4 cards in a row and one below it, so just scrap that.
- The little colored number titled “the amount of money “player” bet for this betting round” should just disappear when they fold instead of staying on the board as 0.
- What would help new players is a little text below their hand telling them what they currently have, and if you can afford to program it, maybe even a percentage chance of winning like they do in real tournaments.
- There should be chips that say small and big blind, like the dealer chip, instead of a chat bubble above the players saying “I placed a small blind”
- When a player is eliminated, their whole presence should be wiped from the board, as opposed to keeping a large empty semi-transparent box with their name in it and no cards.
- A player’s cards should be greyed out when they fold, instead of disappearing, so they can still see what they ‘would’ve’ had if they continued to play.
Hope these suggestions help you, if you choose to implement some or all of them great, but in either case, thanks for adding this to BGA and good luck with the continued development of your game!
Sincerely,
steal36 • Apa browser yang Anda gunakan?
Google Chrome v137
-
• Harap salin/tempel teks yang ditampilkan dalam bahasa Inggris alih-alih bahasa anda. Jika kamu memunyai screenshot dari sebuah kesalahan (praktik bagus) kamu busa menggunakan gambar untuk menandakan pilihan servis anda (snipboard.io for example) untuk mengunggah itu dan salin/tempel tautan disini apakah teks ini tersedia dalam translation system? jika iya, itu bisa diartikan lebih dari 24 jam
Hello, I’m steal36 and I just played your game for the first time. I like it a lot! I haven’t experienced any major bugs and it all ran very smoothly as a poker game should. However, I noticed a few small things that could be slightly edited in order to enhance the player experience, if you are open to feedback that is. Allow me to list my initial observations and ideas for you. (Note: I'm aware BGA requests to write one bug per report but I have too many to list them all sepparately so forgive me if this is a lot, and some might repeat what other users have suggested).
- There should be a slider dial to decide how much to bid. I’m not a fan of the current system with 6 options up top plus a custom option where you have to enter a number, it’s just clunky. Give us a slider near our tokens, give us the option to bid small, half or all in, and then a confirm button.
Side note: I didn’t initially see all the toggleable settings under the table screen (and mind you I am playing on the widest display option on a MacBook Pro) because I had to scroll down for it. So a lot of my initial suggestions when I started writing this were all things that you’ve already implemented the option for. What I’d suggest instead is bringing up those options (there’s space for it on the board) or an other form of indication that they’re there, otherwise players might miss it if they don’t think to scroll.
- Small bug I noticed, halfway through the game I unselected the “ask to reveal hands” option and then a few rounds later reselected it, but it wouldn’t give me the cue to reveal my cards anymore. For that reason I wasn’t able to test this next point but in case there isn’t a time limit:
- There should be a time limit on the option to reveal or not show cards.
- There should be less crowding in the actions summary section (not sure what its called), just the important information on how much each player bets, i.e. “player bets 4” “player raises 6”, no need for “__ is now the active player” and no need to notify us every time money moves from a player to their betting pile and from the betting pile to the pot its just too much. You could even remove the game moves like “a 4 is revealed” when I can already see that on the board. No need for “cards have been shuffled” “2 was dealt to each player” etc.
Additionally, the hands at the end don’t fully fit in the recap so it looks clunky cause its 4 cards in a row and one below it, so just scrap that.
- The little colored number titled “the amount of money “player” bet for this betting round” should just disappear when they fold instead of staying on the board as 0.
- What would help new players is a little text below their hand telling them what they currently have, and if you can afford to program it, maybe even a percentage chance of winning like they do in real tournaments.
- There should be chips that say small and big blind, like the dealer chip, instead of a chat bubble above the players saying “I placed a small blind”
- When a player is eliminated, their whole presence should be wiped from the board, as opposed to keeping a large empty semi-transparent box with their name in it and no cards.
- A player’s cards should be greyed out when they fold, instead of disappearing, so they can still see what they ‘would’ve’ had if they continued to play.
Hope these suggestions help you, if you choose to implement some or all of them great, but in either case, thanks for adding this to BGA and good luck with the continued development of your game!
Sincerely,
steal36 • Apa browser yang Anda gunakan?
Google Chrome v137
-
• Tolong jelaskan saran Anda secara tepat dan ringkas sehingga semudah mungkin untuk memahami apa yang Anda maksud.
Hello, I’m steal36 and I just played your game for the first time. I like it a lot! I haven’t experienced any major bugs and it all ran very smoothly as a poker game should. However, I noticed a few small things that could be slightly edited in order to enhance the player experience, if you are open to feedback that is. Allow me to list my initial observations and ideas for you. (Note: I'm aware BGA requests to write one bug per report but I have too many to list them all sepparately so forgive me if this is a lot, and some might repeat what other users have suggested).
- There should be a slider dial to decide how much to bid. I’m not a fan of the current system with 6 options up top plus a custom option where you have to enter a number, it’s just clunky. Give us a slider near our tokens, give us the option to bid small, half or all in, and then a confirm button.
Side note: I didn’t initially see all the toggleable settings under the table screen (and mind you I am playing on the widest display option on a MacBook Pro) because I had to scroll down for it. So a lot of my initial suggestions when I started writing this were all things that you’ve already implemented the option for. What I’d suggest instead is bringing up those options (there’s space for it on the board) or an other form of indication that they’re there, otherwise players might miss it if they don’t think to scroll.
- Small bug I noticed, halfway through the game I unselected the “ask to reveal hands” option and then a few rounds later reselected it, but it wouldn’t give me the cue to reveal my cards anymore. For that reason I wasn’t able to test this next point but in case there isn’t a time limit:
- There should be a time limit on the option to reveal or not show cards.
- There should be less crowding in the actions summary section (not sure what its called), just the important information on how much each player bets, i.e. “player bets 4” “player raises 6”, no need for “__ is now the active player” and no need to notify us every time money moves from a player to their betting pile and from the betting pile to the pot its just too much. You could even remove the game moves like “a 4 is revealed” when I can already see that on the board. No need for “cards have been shuffled” “2 was dealt to each player” etc.
Additionally, the hands at the end don’t fully fit in the recap so it looks clunky cause its 4 cards in a row and one below it, so just scrap that.
- The little colored number titled “the amount of money “player” bet for this betting round” should just disappear when they fold instead of staying on the board as 0.
- What would help new players is a little text below their hand telling them what they currently have, and if you can afford to program it, maybe even a percentage chance of winning like they do in real tournaments.
- There should be chips that say small and big blind, like the dealer chip, instead of a chat bubble above the players saying “I placed a small blind”
- When a player is eliminated, their whole presence should be wiped from the board, as opposed to keeping a large empty semi-transparent box with their name in it and no cards.
- A player’s cards should be greyed out when they fold, instead of disappearing, so they can still see what they ‘would’ve’ had if they continued to play.
Hope these suggestions help you, if you choose to implement some or all of them great, but in either case, thanks for adding this to BGA and good luck with the continued development of your game!
Sincerely,
steal36 • Apa browser yang Anda gunakan?
Google Chrome v137
Laporkan riwayat
Tambahkan hal lain di laporan ini
- ID meja / nomor langkah lainnya
- Apakah F5 menyelesaikan masalah?
- Apakah masalah tersebut telah muncul beberapa kali? Setiap kali? Tidak tentu?
- Jika kamu memunyai screenshot dari sebuah kesalahan (praktik bagus) kamu busa menggunakan gambar untuk menandakan pilihan servis anda (snipboard.io for example) untuk mengunggah itu dan salin/tempel tautan disini
